First author, year of publication | N= | Recruitment method* | Age | Female/male | MRI | Contrast | Area scanned | Uni/bilateral | Score Method | Blinded† |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scored without a validated method | ||||||||||
Wrist+MCP summed | ||||||||||
Nakahara et al, 199611 | 10 | NP | NP | 5/5 | 1.5T | Gd+ | Wrist+MCP | NP | Described | + |
Lindegaard et al, 200112 | 3 | Hospital staff | 46 (34–55) | 1/2 | 0.2T | Gd+ | Wrist+MCP | Unilateral | Described | + |
Yoshioka et al, 200613 | 13 | NP | 34.1 (22–48) | 5/8 | 0.21T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP+PIP | Bilateral | NP | + |
Offidani et al, 199814 | 12 | NP | NP | NP | 1.0T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP+IP | NP | Described | + |
Wrist | ||||||||||
Beltran et al, 198715 | 6 | NP | NP | NP | 1.5T | Gd− | Wrist | NP | Described | NP |
Jorgensen et al, 199316 | 4 | NP | 30 | 2/2 | 0.5T | Gd+ | Wrist | NP | NP | + |
Yanagawa et al, 199317 | 10 | NP | NP | 7/3 | 1.5T | Gd+ | Wrist | NP | NP | + |
Østergaard et al, 199518 | 3 | NP | 30 (28–31) | NP | 1.5T | Gd+ | Wrist | NP | NP | + |
Tonolli-Serabian et al, 199619 | 10 | NP | 59 (46–71) | 5/5 | 1.0T | Gd+ | Wrist | Bilateral | Described | + |
Pierre-Jerome et al, 199720 | 42 | NP | 42.1 | 42/0 | 0.5T | Gd− | Wrist | Bilateral | Described | NP |
Valeri et al, 200121 | 12 | NP | 31 | 8/4 | 1.0T | Gd− | Wrist | Bilateral | Described | NP |
Partik et al, 200222 | 18 | NP | 30,8 (24–34) | 9/9 | 1.0T | Gd+ | Wrist | NP | NP | NP |
Robertson et al, 200623 | 30 | Hospital staff and contacts | 31 (22–49) | 17/13 | 1.5T | Gd+ | Wrist | Unilateral | Described | NP |
MCP | ||||||||||
McGonagle et al, 199924 | 31 | Hospital staff | 48 (28–62) | 18/13 | 1.5T | Gd− | MCP | Unilateral | Described | + |
Klarlund et al, 199925 | 3 | NP | 31 (24–33) | NP | 1.0T | Gd+ | MCP | Unilateral | Described | + |
Vlychou et al, 201326 | 5 | 2 volunteers and with 3 wrist instability<AQ: Please rephrase for clarity.> | 41.2±3.2 | 3/2 | 3.0T | Gd+ | MCP+PIP+DIP | Unilateral | Described | + |
Scored according to RAMRIS | ||||||||||
Wrist+MCP summed | ||||||||||
Brown et al, 200629 | 17 | NP | 38 | 12/5 | 1.5T | Gd+ | Wrist+MCP | Unilateral | RAMRIS | + |
Ejbjerg et al, 200430 | 28 | NP | 47 (24–67) | 20/8 | 1.0T | Gd+ | Wrist+MCP | Unilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
Olech et al, 201031 | 40 | Hospital staff | 36.7 (20–64) | 29/11 | 0.2T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP | Bilateral | RAMRIS | + |
Parodi et al, 200632 | 23 | Healthy relatives | 59 (25–86) | 16/7 | 0.2T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP+PIP | Bilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
Ejbjerg et al, 200533 | 9 | NP | NP | NP | 0.2T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP+MTP | Bilateral | RAMRIS | + |
Duer-Jensen et al, 201134 | 24 | NP | 46 (21–71) | 17/7 | 0.6 T (12), 1.0 T (12) | Gd+ | Wrist+MCP+PIP | Unilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
Wrist | ||||||||||
Cimmino et al, 201135 | 13 | NP | 71 (57–86) | NP | 0.2T | Gd— | Wrist | Bilateral | RAMRIS | + |
Palosaari et al, 200936 | 31 | Hospital staff | 49 (32–64) | 18/13 | 0.23T | Gd+ (10/31) | Wrist | Bilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
Døhn et al, 200837 | 4 | NP | 36 (34-57) | 3/1 | 0.6T | Gd− | Wrist | Unilateral | RAMRIS | + |
MCP | ||||||||||
Døhn et al, 200638 | 4 | NP | 35.5 (34–57) | 3/1 | 0.6T | Gd− | MCP | Unilateral | RAMRIS | + |
Tan et al, 200339 | 28 | NP | 40 | 19/9 | 1.5T | Gd+ (8/28) | MCP | Unilateral | RAMRIS | + |
Miese et al, 201240 | 13 | NP | 51±12 (25–66) | 10/3 | 3T | Gd+ | MCP (dig 2&3) | Unilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
Mean grading (Wrist+MCP) | ||||||||||
Xie et al, 200827 | 14 | NP | 25±5 (19–33) | 4/10 | 1.0T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP | Bilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
27 | NP | 62±7 (49–74) | 22/5 | 1.0T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP | 24/27 Bilateral | RAMRIS | NP | |
Krabben et al, 201310 | 19 | NP | 46.2±11.8 | 15/4 | 1,5T | Gd− | Wrist+MCP+MTP | Unilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
Rastogi et al, 201328 | 10 | NP | (24–40) | 7/3 | 3T | Gd+ | Wrist | Unilateral | RAMRIS | NP |
*Description of recruitment of symptom-free persons.
†Scoring was done blind for the status (patient/symptom-free person).
described, articles that do describe their scoring method but not according to the RAMRIS method; DIP, distal interphalangeal joint; Gd, gadolinium; IP, interphalangeal joint; MCP, metacarpophalangeal joints; MTP, metatarsophalangeal; NP, Not provided; PIP, proximal interphalangeal joint; T, tesla.