Table 1

Reliability of scoring synovitis in static images and in patients with RA

IntraobserverInterobserver
Static imagesStatic images
Prevalence % (min–max)Observed agreement(min–max)Kappa (y/n)+95% CI(min–max)Kappa (0–3)(min–max)Prevalence % (mean)Observed agreement(mean)Mean Kkappa (y/n)+95% CIMean Kkappa (0 to 3)+95% CI
GS*Grade 0: 3.1–17.20.66–0.94−0.05 to 0.94 (0–1 to 0.7–1)0.59–0.92 (0.1–0.65 to 0.7–0.94)Grade 0: 11.80.770.71 (0.16 to 0.73)0.76 (0.08 to 0.78)
Grade 1: 4.7–25Grade 1: 14.0
Grade 2: 28.1–57.8Grade 2: 43.9
Grade 3: 6.3–42.2Grade 3: 30.3
PDGrade 0: 57.8–59.40.89–11–1 (0.89–1 to 1)0.89–1 (0.7–0.94 to 0.38–1)Grade 0: 59.30.820.98 (0.98 to 1)0.94 (0.92 to 1)
Grade 1: 1.6–21.9Grade 1: 7.9
Grade 2: 14.1–32.8Grade 2: 22.4
Grade 3: 6.3–18.8Grade 3: 10.4