Study acronym | Interventions | No. of patients* | Time point (weeks) | Primary outcome | Included in efficacy networks |
ACTIVE33–35 | Apremilast 30 mg PO BID | 110 | 16 | ACR20 at week 16 | ACR |
Placebo | 109 | ||||
ADEPT36–38 | Adalimumab 40 mg SC Q2W | 151 | 12 | ACR20 at week 12; mTSS score change from baseline to week 24 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Placebo | 162 | ||||
ASTRAEA39 40 | Abatacept 125 mg SC Q1W | 213 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR |
Placebo | 211 | ||||
FUTURE 231 38 41–44 | Secukinumab 150 mg SC Q4W | 100 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR†, PASI†, PsARC† |
Secukinumab 300 mg SC Q4W | 100 | ||||
Placebo | 98 | ||||
FUTURE 345 | Secukinumab 150 mg SC Q4W | 138 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR |
Secukinumab 300 mg SC Q4W | 139 | ||||
Placebo | 137 | ||||
FUTURE 446 | Secukinumab 150 mg SC Q4W | 114 | 16 | ACR20 at week 16 | ACR, PASI† |
Placebo | 114 | ||||
FUTURE 5 47 48 | Secukinumab 150 mg SC Q4W | 220 | 12/16‡ | ACR20 at week 16 | ACR, PASI† |
Secukinumab 300 mg SC Q4W | 222 | ||||
Placebo | 332 | ||||
49 | Adalimumab 40 mg SC Q2W | 51 | 12 | ACR20 at week 12 | ACR, PsARC |
Placebo | 49 | ||||
GO-REVEAL50 51 | Golimumab 50 mg SC Q4W | 146 | 14 | ACR20 at week 14 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Placebo | 113 | ||||
IMPACT52 | Infliximab 5 mg/kg IV Q8W | 52 | 14/16/16‡ | ACR20 at week 16 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Placebo | 52 | ||||
IMPACT 253 54 | Infliximab 5 mg/kg IV Q8W | 100 | 14 | ACR20 at week 14 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Placebo | 100 | ||||
M14-197§55 56 | Adalimumab 40 mg SC Q2W | 72 | 12 | ACR20 at week 12 | |
Placebo | 24 | ||||
57 | Etanercept 25 mg BIW/50 mg Q1W | 30 | 12 | PsARC at week 12 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Placebo | 30 | ||||
58 | Etanercept 25 mg BIW/50 mg Q1W | 101 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR, PsARC |
Placebo | 104 | ||||
59 | Abatacept 10 mg/kg IV Q4W | 40 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR†, PASI† |
Placebo | 42 | ||||
OPAL BEYOND§60–62 | Tofacitinib 5 mg PO BID | 131 | 12 | ACR20 at week 12; HAQ-DI change from baseline to week 12 | |
Placebo | 131 | ||||
OPAL BROADEN62–65 | Adalimumab 40 mg SC Q2W | 106 | 12 | ACR20 at week 12; HAQ-DI change from baseline to week 12 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Tofacitinib 5 mg PO BID | 107 | ||||
Placebo | 105 | ||||
PALACE 138 66–68 | Apremilast 30 mg PO BID | 168 | 16 | ACR20 at week 16 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Placebo | 168 | ||||
PALACE 269 | Apremilast 30 mg PO BID | 162 | 16 | ACR20 at week 16 | ACR, PASI†, PsARC† |
Placebo | 159 | ||||
PALACE 370 | Apremilast 30 mg PO BID | 167 | 16 | ACR20 at week 16 | ACR, PASI† |
Placebo | 169 | ||||
PSUMMIT 138 71 72 | Ustekinumab 45 mg SC Q12W | 205 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR, PASI |
Ustekinumab 90 mg SC Q12W | 204 | ||||
Placebo | 206 | ||||
PSUMMIT 2 38 73 | Ustekinumab 45 mg SC Q12W | 103 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR, PASI |
Ustekinumab 90 mg SC Q12W | 105 | ||||
Placebo | 104 | ||||
RAPID-PsA38 74–78 | Certolizumab pegol (pooled doses) | 273 | 12 | ACR20 at week 12; mTSS change from baseline to week 24 | ACR, PASI, PsARC† |
Placebo | 136 | ||||
SPIRIT-P179–84 | Ixekizumab 80 mg SC Q2W | 103 | 12 | ACR20 at week 24 | ACR, PASI, PsARC |
Ixekizumab 80 mg SC Q4W | 107 | ||||
Adalimumab 40 mg SC Q2W | 101 | ||||
Placebo | 106 | ||||
SPIRIT-P2§85–90 | Ixekizumab 80 mg SC Q2W | 123 | ACR20 at week 24 | ||
Ixekizumab 80 mg SC Q4W | 122 | ||||
Placebo | 118 |
*Patient numbers are for the intent-to-treat population.
†Data presented for the overall population of bDMARD-naïve and bDMARD-experienced patients.
‡Time points for ACR/PASI or ACR/PASI/PsARC.
§Studies in bDMARD-experienced patients only and were therefore included in the safety evaluation but not the efficacy evaluation in the base-case analyses.
ACR, American College of Rheumatology; bDMARD, biologic disease-modifying antirheumatic drug; BID, two times per day; BIW, twice weekly; HAQ-DI, Health Assessment Questionnaire-Disability Index; IV, intravenously; mTSS, modified Total Sharp Score; PASI, Psoriasis Area and Severity Index; PO, orally; PsA, psoriatic arthritis; PsARC, Psoriatic Arthritis Response Criteria; QxW, every x weeks; SC, subcutaneously.