Table 2

Humoral and cellular responses to vaccine according to treatment received: comparison between cohort 1 (immunocompromised, IMRD ISP+) and cohort 2 (immunocompetent, IMRD ISP−)

AntimalarialsIL-6iTNFiMTXAbataceptBMBMFMAZALFMRTXTNF/IL-6i+MTXRTX+MTXBMB+MTX
n (%)19 (42)10 (22)10 (22)21 (21)10 (10)8 (8)10 (10)7 (7)6 (6)16 (16)7 (7)10 (10)5 (5)
Seroconversion rate (n, %)17 (89)9 (90)9 (90)13 (62)1 (10)4 (50)8 (80)4 (57)6 (100)5 (31)6 (85)3 (30)2 (40)
 p* (cohort 1)0.04*0.110.120.960.008*0.470.260.910.180.03*0.260.050.09
 p** (cohort 2)0.400.490.490.04*0.001*0.04*0.760.180.600.007*0.770.003*0.01*
IgG anti-spike levels mean±SD (BAU/mL)594.3±264611±272543±298313±29113±37255±241323±250178±142572±228133±263356±246123±208232±198
 p* (cohort 1)0.190.310.320.710.004*0.720.003*0.280.210.070.2670.04*0.81
 p** (cohort 2)0.970.790.610.02*0.002*0.04*0.03*0.01*0.920.002*0.770.01*0.03*
CD4 T-cell response (n, %)17 (89)8 (80)10 (100)17 (80)1 (10)5 (63)7 (70)3 (42)6 (100)8 (50)6 (85)5 (50)3 (60)
 p* (cohort 1)0.03*0.220.070.080.03*0.880.110.640.160.490.200.550.99
 p** (cohort 2)0.190.710.170.560.003*0.470.270.080.450.080.520.140.49
CD8 T-cell response (n, %)17 (89)8 (80)10 (100)16 (76)2 (20)5 (63)7 (70)3 (42)6 (100)8 (50)6 (85)5 (50)3 (60)
 p* (cohort 1)0.03*0.190.060.120.150.780.170.600.490.580.180.650.91
 p† (cohort 2)0.190.490.170.880.01*0.550.520.080.170.080.520.130.49
  • p* refers to comparison between each treatment group with the rest of cohort 1 (IMRD ISP+).

  • p** refers to comparison between each treatment group with cohort 2 (IMRD ISP−).

  • AZA, azathioprine; BAU, binding antibody unit; BMB, belimumab; IL-6i, IL-6 inhibitors; IMRD, immune-mediated inflammatory rheumatic disease; LFM, leflunomide; MFM, mycophenolate; MTX, methotrexate; RTX, rituximab.