Table 3

Study characteristics—studies evaluating peripheral joint disease

StudySub-phenotypeMajor phenotypes*Other descriptionsPhysical exam— providerOther evaluationImaging†Subjects imaged
Al-Jarallah et al 201233YesDactylitis, enthesitisType 1/type 2Yes—other
Al-Jarallah et al 201334YesDactylitis, enthesitisType 1/type 2Yes—other
Bandinelli et al 201124YesEnthesitisYes—RheumUSaSx
Bandyopadhyay et al 201536YesOtherType 1/type 2Yes—Rheum
Barreiro-de Acosta et al 200737NoYes—Rheum
Bertolini et al 202038YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgiaYes—RheumUSSx/aSx
Beslek et al 200939YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis, enthesitisChronic arthritisYes—Rheum
Christodoulou et al 200240YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis, arthralgiaNoSelf-report, chart
D’Inca et al 200941YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis, polyarthritis, arthralgiaSymmetrical arthritis,‡ fibromyalgia, tendinitisYes—RheumBone scintigraphySx
DeVlam et al 200042YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgiaPolyarticular asymmetricYes—Rheum
Ditisheim et al 201543NoNoSelf-report
Duricova et al 201745NoYes—OtherChart
Fatemi et al 201646YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, arthralgiaFibromyalgiaYes—Rheum
Hammoudeh et al 201848YesEnthesitis, arthralgiaType 1/type 2Yes—Rheum
Isene et al 201550NoYes—Other
Kamo et al 201551YesDactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgiaNoSelf-report
Karmiris et al 201652YesArthralgiaMonoarthralgia/oligoarthralgia, polyarthralgiaYes—Rheum
Lakatos et al 200353YesOtherType 1/type 2Yes—Rheum
Lanna et al 200854YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, enthesitisAsymmetric arthritis,§ inflammatory arthalgia¶Yes—RheumX-raySx/aSx
Luchetti et al 201955YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, enthesitisOA, fibromyalgiaYes—RheumUSSx
Mocelin et al 201556NoNo**FibromyalgiaNoChart
Ossum et al 2018: Peripheral14YesDactylitis, enthesitispArthritis, pSpANoSelf-reportX-raySx
Palm et al 200115YesPolyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitisSymmetrical arthritis,‡ OAYes—RheumX-raySx
Peeters et al 200858NoNoChart
Picchianti-Diamanti et al 202059YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis††Type 1/type 2Yes—RheumUS
Pokharna et al 200460YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis, arthralgiaYes—OtherX-raySx/aSx
Queiro et al 200061NoAsymmetric arthritis§Yes—OtherX-raySx/aSx
Rovisco et al 201663YesEnthesitisYes—RheumUSSx/aSx
Salvarani et al 200165YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitisYes—Rheum
Stolwijk et al 201367YesDactylitis, enthesitisFibromyalgiaNoSelf-report, chart
Subramaniam et al 201568YesDactylitis, enthesitisNoSelf-report, chart
Turkcapar et al 200669YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitisYes—RheumX-raySx/aSx
Van Erp et al 201670YesMonoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgiaYes—OtherX-raySx
Vavricka et al 2011NoNoPhysician survey
Yuksel et al 201171YesArthralgiaSymmetrical arthritis,‡ fibromyalgia, tendinitisYes-RheumX-raySx
  • *Peripheral phenotypes: monoarthritis/oligoarthritis, polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgia.

  • †Peripheral Imaging only.

  • ‡Did not specify polyarthritis.

  • §Number of joints not specified.

  • ¶Noted no swelling but did not define further.

  • **Joint symptoms reported exclusively as arthralgia—no mention of arthritis.

  • ††Ultrasound recorded synovial hypertrophy, enthesitis and tenosynovitis, but did not report enthesitis separately.

  • OA, osteoarthritis; pArthritis, peripheral arthritis; pSpA, peripheral spondyloarthritis; Rheum, rheumatologist; US, Ultrasound; Sx, symptomatic; aSx, asymptomatic