Study characteristics—studies evaluating peripheral joint disease
Study | Sub-phenotype | Major phenotypes* | Other descriptions | Physical exam— provider | Other evaluation | Imaging† | Subjects imaged |
Al-Jarallah et al 201233 | Yes | Dactylitis, enthesitis | Type 1/type 2 | Yes—other | – | – | – |
Al-Jarallah et al 201334 | Yes | Dactylitis, enthesitis | Type 1/type 2 | Yes—other | – | – | – |
Bandinelli et al 201124 | Yes | Enthesitis | – | Yes—Rheum | – | US | aSx |
Bandyopadhyay et al 201536 | Yes | Other | Type 1/type 2 | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Barreiro-de Acosta et al 200737 | No | – | – | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Bertolini et al 202038 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgia | – | Yes—Rheum | – | US | Sx/aSx |
Beslek et al 200939 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis, enthesitis | Chronic arthritis | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Christodoulou et al 200240 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis, arthralgia | – | No | Self-report, chart | – | – |
D’Inca et al 200941 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis, polyarthritis, arthralgia | Symmetrical arthritis,‡ fibromyalgia, tendinitis | Yes—Rheum | – | Bone scintigraphy | Sx |
DeVlam et al 200042 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgia | Polyarticular asymmetric | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Ditisheim et al 201543 | No | – | – | No | Self-report | – | – |
Duricova et al 201745 | No | – | – | Yes—Other | Chart | – | – |
Fatemi et al 201646 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, arthralgia | Fibromyalgia | Yes—Rheum | — | — | — |
Hammoudeh et al 201848 | Yes | Enthesitis, arthralgia | Type 1/type 2 | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Isene et al 201550 | No | – | – | Yes—Other | – | – | – |
Kamo et al 201551 | Yes | Dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgia | – | No | Self-report | – | – |
Karmiris et al 201652 | Yes | Arthralgia | Monoarthralgia/oligoarthralgia, polyarthralgia | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Lakatos et al 200353 | Yes | Other | Type 1/type 2 | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Lanna et al 200854 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, enthesitis | Asymmetric arthritis,§ inflammatory arthalgia¶ | Yes—Rheum | – | X-ray | Sx/aSx |
Luchetti et al 201955 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, enthesitis | OA, fibromyalgia | Yes—Rheum | – | US | Sx |
Mocelin et al 201556 | No | No** | Fibromyalgia | No | Chart | – | – |
Ossum et al 2018: Peripheral14 | Yes | Dactylitis, enthesitis | pArthritis, pSpA | No | Self-report | X-ray | Sx |
Palm et al 200115 | Yes | Polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis | Symmetrical arthritis,‡ OA | Yes—Rheum | – | X-ray | Sx |
Peeters et al 200858 | No | – | – | No | Chart | – | – |
Picchianti-Diamanti et al 202059 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis†† | Type 1/type 2 | Yes—Rheum | – | US | – |
Pokharna et al 200460 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis, arthralgia | – | Yes—Other | – | X-ray | Sx/aSx |
Queiro et al 200061 | No | – | Asymmetric arthritis§ | Yes—Other | – | X-ray | Sx/aSx |
Rovisco et al 201663 | Yes | Enthesitis | – | Yes—Rheum | – | US | Sx/aSx |
Salvarani et al 200165 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis | – | Yes—Rheum | – | – | – |
Stolwijk et al 201367 | Yes | Dactylitis, enthesitis | Fibromyalgia | No | Self-report, chart | – | – |
Subramaniam et al 201568 | Yes | Dactylitis, enthesitis | – | No | Self-report, chart | – | – |
Turkcapar et al 200669 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis | – | Yes—Rheum | – | X-ray | Sx/aSx |
Van Erp et al 201670 | Yes | Monoarthritis/oligoarthritis/polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgia | – | Yes—Other | – | X-ray | Sx |
Vavricka et al 2011 | No | – | – | No | Physician survey | – | – |
Yuksel et al 201171 | Yes | Arthralgia | Symmetrical arthritis,‡ fibromyalgia, tendinitis | Yes-Rheum | – | X-ray | Sx |
*Peripheral phenotypes: monoarthritis/oligoarthritis, polyarthritis, dactylitis, enthesitis, arthralgia.
†Peripheral Imaging only.
‡Did not specify polyarthritis.
§Number of joints not specified.
¶Noted no swelling but did not define further.
**Joint symptoms reported exclusively as arthralgia—no mention of arthritis.
††Ultrasound recorded synovial hypertrophy, enthesitis and tenosynovitis, but did not report enthesitis separately.
OA, osteoarthritis; pArthritis, peripheral arthritis; pSpA, peripheral spondyloarthritis; Rheum, rheumatologist; US, Ultrasound; Sx, symptomatic; aSx, asymptomatic