- •
Clinical practice guidelines are tools used to assist health care professionals in clinical decision making with the ultimate goal of improving patient care.
- •
Promoting the implementation of clinical practice guidelines at the point of care delivery is a hurdle to translating scientific findings into practice.
- •
As access to electronic evidence sources increase, the amount of evidence available to clinicians for clinical decision support is overwhelming.
- •
Increased adoption of electronic health
Utilization of Clinical Practice Guidelines: Barriers and Facilitators
Section snippets
Key points
Utilization of clinical practice guidelines: barriers and facilitators
Clinical practice guidelines are designed to improve quality of care, reduce variation in practice and ensure evidence-based care is delivered when appropriate. Despite the creation of guidelines at national and international levels, guidelines are underutilized by clinicians at the bedside to improve patient care. Clinical practice guidelines are “systematically developed statements to assist practitioners and patients to make decisions about appropriate health care for specific circumstances.”
Statement of the problem
Decisions about when, why, and how to pursue certain diagnoses and treatments are complicated. Patient care interventions are based on scientific principles, theoretical knowledge, and a clinician’s expertise. Clinical practice guidelines exist as tools to augment clinician decision making, yet several barriers to implementation have been identified in the literature. Researchers cite a lack of knowledge of guideline existence, complexity of guidelines, staff attitude, lack of training, time,
Purpose
The purpose of this project was to seek an understanding of what factors promote or prevent the implementation of evidence-based clinical practice guidelines at the point of care delivery using a population of neuroscience advanced practice providers.
Background
Even with the exponential growth of publicly available clinical practice guidelines, ease of access to high-quality evidence is out of reach for many clinicians. As access to electronic evidence sources increases, the amount of evidence available to clinicians for clinical decision support is overwhelming. It is often difficult for providers to stay current with the evidence necessary to provide the standard of care. In practice, clinicians use experience, education, literature, a patient’s
Health care
The Institute of Medicine’s Promoting Adoption of Clinical Practice Guidelines report challenges the health care community to create systems from within that promote the uptake and use of clinical practice guidelines at the point of care.16 The Institute of Medicine recognizes this as one of the main steps in translating research findings into the mainstream of practice. A growing body of evidence shows that the rate of clinical practice guideline adoption is affected by the interaction of the
Impact of project on population
Adherence to well-designed clinical practice guidelines is recognized as a strategy to reduce error and improve outcomes for neuroscience patients. Neurosurgical and cerebrovascular adverse events such as thromboembolic events, infection, wrong level surgery, management of vasospasm, and salt wasting syndromes are complications likely be reduced by use of evidence-based guidelines and protocols.22 In recent years, professional medical and nursing organizations attempted to monitor effects on
Application of theoretic framework
Although clinical practice guidelines encourage the consistent, efficient application of evidence when used by clinicians at the bedside, a knowledge translation gap exists.25 Social, cognitive, and motivational factors enable efficient knowledge translation in an organization.25 The interrelationship between several concepts impacts the utilization of clinical practice guidelines in clinical practice (Fig. 2).
The literature reveals many barriers and facilitators that impede the successful
Project Design
The purpose of this project was to assess factors that negatively or positively influenced advanced practice provider utilization of clinical practice guidelines in a community hospital. The method in this project was described in both a broad and narrow context relevant to neuroscience advanced practice provider clinical practice. A nonexperimental, cross-sectional, descriptive design was used to gather qualitative and quantitative data via survey. The project was approved by the institutional
Results
In assessing advanced practice provider use of clinical practice guidelines, statements and open-ended questions related to knowledge, attitude, and behaviors were evaluated via survey. Frequency distribution tables of results were constructed for both clinical practice guidelines in general and the hospital specific anticoagulation reversal guidelines (Tables 2 and 4). An overall response rate to determine the score and mean related to all the statements was calculated. Before computing the
Relationship of Results to Framework
Individual professional decisions were central to the execution of clinical practice guidelines, understanding perceptions to similar clinical scenarios of patients encountered on a daily basis were integral to recommending approaches to improve adherence. Responses to open-ended questions regarding these high-acuity scenarios were evaluated to attain insight into factors that promote or prevent adherence to the use of clinical practice guidelines. Striking similarities in correct responses of
Acknowledgments
The author gratefully acknowledges the support and guidance of S.D. Krau, PhD, CNE Associate Professor, School of Nursing, Vanderbilt University and C. Thomson-Smith, MSN, RN, JD, FAANP, Assistant Dean Faculty Practice & Assistant Professor, School of Nursing, Vanderbilt University.
References (30)
- et al.
Facilitators and barriers to clinical practice guideline use among nurses
Am J Nurs
(2012) - et al.
Nurses’ experiences of guideline implementation: a focus group study
J Clin Nurs
(2009) - et al.
Factors influencing adherence to an emergency department national protocol
Eur J Emerg Med
(2012) - et al.
Adherence to guidelines and protocols in the prehospital and emergency care setting: a systematic review
Scand J Trauma Rescue Emerg Med
(2013) - Legal Dictionary. Standard of Care definition. 2014. Available at:...
Nurse practitioner’s business practice and legal Guide
(2012)- et al.
Managing clinical knowledge for health care improvement
The gap between evidence and practice
Health Aff (Millwood)
(2007)Anti-coagulant associated intracerebral hemorrhage
Semin Neurol
(2010)
Challenges and controversies in the medical management of primary and antithrombotic-related intracerebral hemorrhage
Ther Adv Neurol Disord
Oral anticoagulant-associated intracerebral hemorrhage
J Neurol
Treatment of warfarin-associated intracerebral hemorrhage: literature review and expert opinion
Mayo Clin Proc
The basics of FMEA
Cited by (39)
The Effect of Modified Early Warning Score (MEWS) and Nursing Guide Application on Postoperative Patient Outcomes: A Randomized Controlled Study
2024, Journal of Perianesthesia NursingNurses' Experiences With Anal Dilatations in Babies With Anorectal Malformations – A Focus Group Interview Study
2023, Journal of Pediatric SurgeryRecommendations for Psychosocial Evaluation of VAD candidates: Adoption, completion, and barriers to implementation
2022, Heart and LungCitation Excerpt :However, there are barriers to adoption, completion, and full implementation of the recommendations. Knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs regarding CPGs impact their use in clinical practice23-24 and while the 2018 Recommendations do not meet the defined standard of a CPG, they offer the most comprehensive framework to guide the PS assessment of candidates for OHT or MCS implantation. The set of core domains and components offer clinicians an avenue to identify issues or barriers to LVAD implantation, create pre- and post-operative patient support plans, maximize both quality and quantity of life post-implantation, and improve both the equity and efficiency of the evaluation process.
Recommendations of the Mexican College of Rheumatology for the Management of Spondyloarthritis
2021, Reumatologia ClinicaValidation of five search filters for retrieval of clinical practice guidelines produced low precision
2020, Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyCitation Excerpt :CPGs are up-to-date evidence-based summaries and consensus-based recommendations that provide a means of answering questions during patient care [1]. CPGs provide standards to improve quality of care, reduce variation in practice, and ensure care is delivered based on patient values and individual preferences [2]. Several surveys of clinicians have reported that use of electronic databases such as MEDLINE is frequently used to retrieve CPGs [3–7].
Disclosure: None.